Are You Giving Your Kids Too Many Choices?

It’s a scene moms are all too familiar with: 

Mom: Come put your dress on for church. 
4-year-old daughter: I don’t want to wear that one!
Mom: Which one do you want?
Daughter: I want the pink one! 
Mom: The pink one is dirty. Would you like to pick a different one? 
Daughter: No! I WANT THE PINK ONE!
Mom (exasperated): You can’t wear that one. How about the one with purple flowers?
Daughter: That one is ugly.
Mom (tosses purple flower dress on the floor): Okay, how about the yellow one from Grandma.
Daughter (pouty lip in full bloom): I don’t LIKE that one.
Mom (tosses yellow dress in the pile): We are running out of choices here. How about the blue and green striped one? 
Daughter (crumbles into heap on the floor and sobs): I just want the pink one! It’s my favorite!

By the time you get out the door you are forty minutes late to church. Your daughter is wearing a dirty pink dress, her bedroom floor is obliterated by the pile of dresses she rejected, and you are flustered. Ironically, your daughter isn’t happy either. Late, dirty, miserable. 

What went wrong?   

Answer: We often treat our kids as if choices are their right instead of their privilege.   

I love giving my kids choices. I like to give a big smile and hold up two snack choices and say, “Which one would you like?” If their eyes light up with excitement I know they remember that choices are a privilege. If the fuss and say, “I don’t want ANY of those!” – then I can tell there has been a shift in their thinking. They think choices are their right and we have some work to do. 

We think we are being kind to our little ones when we give them choices. We think we are teaching them independence and freedom, but often we are actually hurting them by feeding their discontentment. 

It all goes back to our philosophy of mankind. If humans are born naturally good, then by all means give your child as many choices as possible. But, if we admit that they are born naturally sinful, then their hearts need to be trained. Our kids don’t know how to be happy. We have to teach them. They are born knowing how to be miserable, greedy, and discontent. They are not ready for choices yet.

Maybe you’ve experienced this: Your two-year-old sits down to eat and you hand him his yellow spoon. He frowns and throws it on the ground and demands the blue spoon. You glance over at the counter. The blue spoon is sitting right there. Do you give it to him? After all, it’s available so why not? 

Because it’s not about the spoon.

If you give him the blue spoon you might pacify him…for now. Next time he will throw that one on the ground, too. Pretty soon there won’t be enough spoons in the house to satisfy his discontent heart. 

That’s because a discontent heart is a bottomless pit. The best way to give our kids the tools for happiness is to seal off that pit. Limit their choices until they are thankful for what is already in front of them.  

“You may not throw the spoon on the ground. This is the spoon Mommy gave you. You need to be thankful for what you have. Say, ‘Thank you for the spoon, Mommy.'” 

This is training, Moms. They need our help. Of course you will experience resistance when you try this approach for the first time. One option is to take away the spoon altogether. “If you are not thankful for what you have, you may not have anything.” If he continues to fight and fuss he may be excused from the table until he is ready to say thank you. 

Is it okay for kids to have preferences? Of course. We LOVE to hear all about their favorite foods, colors, games, etc., and we always take those feelings into consideration. But here is the important distinction: Their preferences influence decisions; they do not dictate them

The point is not to say no just to say no. Kids will pick up on that and it will become a fruitless power struggle. Instead the point is to carefully select times to say no when you sense that the hungry monster of discontentment has already gained a foothold in your child’s heart. Feeding the monster only makes it grow. That’s when you put your foot down and say, “Because I love you I am not going to give you a choice. I am going to teach you how to be thankful for what you have.”

Think about it from an adult’s perspective. The wealthiest people are often the ones who struggle with contentment the most. With anything and everything at their fingertips, why would they stop at what they already have? They keep changing it and adding to it, but it never makes them happy. We roll our eyes and pity them. But when we give our kids too many choices we are preparing them for that same exact lifestyle. We are training them to be miserable.

“Then when do you let your kids have choices?”

As our kids become firmly established in habits of thankfulness, it’s time to introduce choices. There are two things that show they are ready.

1. When they are already thankful. If your child sits down to dinner with a good attitude, surprise her by giving her a choice. “What would you like to drink tonight? What would you like for dessert?” Choices are given when thankfulness already exists. 

2. When they ask in a respectful way. “Mommy, is it okay if I wear my cowboy boots today?” We love to recognize respectful behavior. We say yes as much as possible to acknowledge that asking respectfully shows they are ready to make choices.

Think about the most thankful person you know. It’s probably not the healthiest, richest, best looking, or most successful person you know, but I bet it’s the happiest. That person is already so content that whatever good thing comes their way is like icing on the cake. Isn’t that what we want for our kids? 

Follow “The Gospel-Centered Mom” on Facebook for daily encouragement! (And anecdotes from my crazy life). 

The Gospel-Centered Mom Bible study is available on Amazon and Etsy!

Photo credit: 

4 thoughts on “Are You Giving Your Kids Too Many Choices?

  1. I don't think your scenario of giving choices is accurate at all. Love and Logic parenting, which I really like, gives some great examples of choices. A more accurate description of mom and daughter in giving choices example would go like this.

    Mom to 4 year old: “Get dressed for church.”
    4 year old: “I don't want to wear that stupid green dress” *cue temper tantrum
    Mom: “Is that how you talk?”
    4 year old, pouting: “No.”
    Mom: “Say please may I wear a different dress.”
    4 year old: “Please Mama.”
    Mom: “Ok, you may choose either the red or the white dress.”
    4 year old is happy and picks red one. Mom is happy too.

    When you offer choices you don't leave them open-ended. You gives choices where you're ok with either outcome. Like, would you like milk or water for dinner? (Don't offer soda.) Would you like to wear the brown or black coat; not do you want to freeze to death with no coat at all? Offering choices is a great way to give kids an element of control within proper boundaries. I believe giving choices goes along with the Biblical principle of “do not exasperate your children.” I have seen FAR too many Christian parents exasperate their children by forcing their kids to do silly things (must be the green dress b/c I said so) that really don't matter.


  2. Anne, I really like your scenario. I think it's a great idea to give limited options. It allows you to train them how to think while still controlling the outcome. The scenario I gave with the daughter and the dresses was more of an extreme showing how NOT to handle the situation. The mom in that situation was held hostage by her daughter's desire to have the final say. Instead of the mom lovingly and firmly limiting the options (like you suggested), she left the whole closet wide open to complaints and anger from her daughter. That will almost always backfire on us and leave our kids more miserable than if we gently took the reigns back and gave more direction. Thanks for the feedback!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: